Trudeau claims response to border crossers shows refugee system is working
OTTAWA - Prime Minister Justin Trudeau sought Wednesday to combat criticism that thousands of people arriving at the Canada-U.S. border to seek asylum are throwing the immigration system into chaos.
On the contrary, he said everything is working as it should.
“I can understand the concerns Canadians share about whether this is a short cut, whether this is somehow uncontrolled immigration,” he said following a meeting in Montreal with federal and provincial officials overseeing response efforts.
“What I'm very pleased to be able to say . . . is that the rules on Canada's immigration system continue to be enforced.”
Nearly 10,000 people have been apprehended at the border since the start of the year as they've sought to enter Canada in order to claim refugee status - almost equivalent to the total number of claims filed for all of 2013. Of those who have arrived this year, nearly 7,000 have arrived just since July, the vast majority at an unofficial crossing point between Quebec and New York.
Temporary camps to house them have been set up at border, and hundreds of others have been bussed to Cornwall, Ont., to be housed there while the preliminary process of applying for asylum begins.
The government has also redeployed dozens of police, border guards and immigration officers to manage the problem and is also now focusing on how to best support the new arrivals while they await a hearing on their refuge claim.
Trudeau said one option being explored is accelerating the process to give them temporary work permits so they'll be less dependent on the temporary social supports in place.
However, Conservative immigration critic Michelle Rempel blasted Trudeau's handling of what she called a crisis.
Camps on the border and asking an already overwhelmed immigration and settlement system to do more with no additional resources is not a solution, she told a news conference Wednesday.
She said the opposition has been raising the issue for months, since the arrivals at the border numbered only in the dozens, but the government's response continues to fall short.
“A photo op after a meeting will not cut it,” she said.
“The prime minister of Canada, in order to help the world's most vulnerable and to salvage the Canadian asylum claim system needs to come up with a credible plan and he needs to explain it to Canadians.”
Many of those who've arrived in Canada have been propelled by changing immigration policy in the United States that began with the inauguration of President Donald Trump and his first attempt in January to block immigration to the U.S. from certain predominantly Muslim countries and halt the refugee program.
In response to that move, Trudeau tweeted: “To those fleeing persecution, terror & war, Canadians will welcome you, regardless of your faith. Diversity is our strength #WelcomeToCanada.”
The message drew attention around the world and it set up expectations among asylum seekers, both the Conservatives and the NDP say.
The NDP also say that Trudeau's current messaging is just as misleading. He repeated Wednesday that those crossing irregularly into Canada will see no special consideration given to their file. But to say there's no advantage to doing so is unfair, NDP immigration critic Jenny Kwan said.
If they go the legal way, she said, they'll be turned away because of the agreement between Canada and the U.S. that precludes people from making asylum claims at official land border crossings. Under international law, once they've crossed the border, Canada must process their claims, she noted.
If Trudeau is serious about stopping the asylum flow, he should suspend the deal, she said.
Trudeau said Wednesday the agreement will remain in place. He said when he talks about there being no advantage, he was speaking of the longer term - claims are assessed on the merits, not based on how someone enters the country.
The Liberals are also continuing their outreach in the U.S. to try and dispel myths circulating there about the Canadian immigration system, Trudeau said, touting Liberal MP Emmanuel Dubourg's trip to Miami to meet members of the Haitian diaspora there.
The vast majority of arrivals in recent weeks have been from Haiti, as the U.S. is currently considering lifting a pause on deportations to that country.
Canada resumed deportations to Haiti this year after its own lengthy pause following a devastating 2010 earthquake in that country.